Mental Health Month 2025: Coffee with a Psychologist
29/09/2025
Surgery, Function, and the Brain: Starting This Journey
24/02/2026
Don’t Believe Everything You Think
When Your Mind’s GPS Gets It Wrong
We all have moments when our thoughts seem convincing — yet not every thought deserves your trust. Challenging automatic thoughts helps you see when your mind’s “GPS” has gone off course, guiding you back toward balance, clarity, and truth.
You’ve probably had this experience: you’re walking down the street and suddenly think, “Everyone’s staring at me.” Or you make a small mistake at work and hear a voice saying, “I’m hopeless at this.” These thoughts arrive fully formed, with the confidence of a breaking news alert. They feel so real you might not even stop to question them.
But here’s the thing — not every thought deserves your trust. Sometimes your brain tells you absolute nonsense. And just because it pops up automatically doesn’t mean you have to believe it.
Think of your mind like Google Maps. Most of the time it gets you where you’re going, but every so often it confidently insists you turn into a dead-end street or drive straight into a river. If you unquestioningly obey, you’ll end up lost, wet, or worse. Automatic thoughts can be the same. They give strong directions, but they’re not always accurate.
Take social situations. You might think, “I said something dumb, now everyone thinks I’m awkward.” Sounds believable in the moment, but if you actually checked, most people either didn’t notice or forgot within seconds. Or imagine facing a challenge at work. Your thought might be, “If I don’t nail this, I’ll be a failure.” That’s not a reflection of reality — that’s your brain spinning a dramatic story.
The problem isn’t just that these thoughts appear. It’s that when we believe them, we act as if they’re true. We avoid people, hold back from opportunities, or beat ourselves up unnecessarily. The thought creates the reality.
But here’s the good news: you can step back. You can catch your mind mid-sentence and say, “Hang on — do I actually need to believe this?”
That simple question opens up choice. Sometimes the thought is useful (“Don’t touch that hot pan”). Other times, it’s just mental static. Learning to notice and challenge your own automatic thoughts is like having a quick look at the route Google Maps has elected for you before you set off — you’re less likely to end up somewhere you didn’t want to go, or making a right turn across 4 lanes of traffic in peak hour...
Try these 2 exercises.
Exercise 1: Thought Checkpoint
- What to do: Next time a strong thought pops up, write it down. Then ask: Is this a fact, or just a story my brain is telling me? What evidence supports it, and what evidence contradicts it?
- Why it works: Separating thoughts from facts helps loosen their grip and gives you a clearer picture of reality.
Exercise 2: The “Maybe” Experiment
- What to do: When a harsh thought arrives (“I’m going to embarrass myself”), add the word “Maybe I’ll embarrass myself.” Then generate an alternative: “Maybe it’ll go fine.” “Maybe people won’t even notice.”
Why it works: Adding maybe turns certainty into possibility. It softens the thought and opens up space for different outcomes.
Your brain is a storyteller, not a news reporter. Some stories are helpful. Others… not so much.
You don’t have to silence your thoughts, and you don’t have to fight them. But you also don’t have to believe every single one. By pausing, questioning, and gently challenging the mental noise, you make room for perspective, balance, and a little more freedom.
By challenging automatic thoughts, you begin to separate fact from feeling, learning that thoughts are not always truths. This shift opens the door to self-compassion, calm, and clearer decision-making.
So next time your mind confidently serves up a negative thought, remember: you don’t HAVE to believe your own bull**** — even when it sounds convincing.
If you want a hand when your mind’s GPS gets it wrong, then reach out to us at Paragon PsychConnect to speak to a Psychologist.
Contact us today to start a conversation with a Psychologist on (08) 7095 3484, or send us a message, if you are interested.
